Would Tim Tebow have gotten the call if he was healthy enough to play? Who knows and no one probably will ever know. McElroy made the most of his chance and he is definitely in the running to start next week at Jacksonville. Why? Because Rex Ryan refused to name a starter for next week, so as long as the door is open, it is an open competition.
So, the question to ask is: who gets the call next week? Vote here on our Sports With The StatMan Facebook page and add your comment.
Should the Jets start third-string Greg McElroy at QB next week against Jacksonville?